January 2003

Sparks Fly Up


"Yet man is born into trouble, as sparks fly upward." Job 5:7


Imagine, if you will, a down-and-out Russian scientist…a germ warfare expert…now a refugee from the dysfunctional Russian economy. He is on the streets of Karachi carrying several small vials. He has a date you see…a rendezvous with a swarthy man carrying a valise filled with 100-dollar bills. Imagine that .

Lewis Simons wrote in the November issue of National Geographic about
a game played by the Federal Government in June 2001. It was called “Dark Winter”. In this scenario, three men, dressed in maintenance uniforms, entered a busy shopping mall one month before Christmas in Oklahoma City. They were carrying plant sprayers—busily spritzing plants and mingling with the holiday shoppers. Other teams of three simultaneously did the same in malls in Philadelphia and Atlanta. The Center For Disease Control announced the first confirmed case of smallpox in Oklahoma City on December 9…followed by more confirmations from Atlanta and Philadelphia. By December 15, the CDC had confirmed 2000 cases of smallpox in 15 states as well as in Canada, Mexico and Great Britain. Emergency Rooms and other clinical facilities were overwhelmed. There was widespread rioting…and the military was deployed on the streets of many U.S. cities. CDC officials, meanwhile, projected that there would be 3 million cases by February…1 million Americans would be dead with no end in sight…

GAME OVER

The Bush administration has decided to vaccinate 10 million Health care workers…plus cops and firefighters for smallpox…according to computer models this in itself will result in 25 to 30 deaths from the vaccine. It will also drain the budgets of county health departments who will bear the brunt of administering these vaccines. The current allocation of 970 million dollars for county health will be gone…which means that other programs like cancer screening and children’s dental go immediately to the back burner.

I don’t think that any of us who were around when the World Health Organization announced that smallpox was eradicated from the planet…perhaps the greatest scientific achievement of the 20th century…had in our worst nightmares dreamed that this horror would come back to haunt us in this particular way.

There is no treatment and no cure for smallpox…and it is a sure thing that 30 % of those exposed to it will die from it. If you get vaccinated within 48 hours of exposure you have a chance…otherwise…well…. Ditto for anthrax…remember anthrax??…there is a vaccine and it can be as lethal as the one for smallpox…inhalation anthrax is not contagious, but it is almost always fatal…funny…those words keep cropping up as I researched this piece….lethal…fatal…maybe this is a topic that should not be discussed in polite conversation…like masturbation or bowel movements…maybe what we don’t know won’t hurt us…then again…

Christopher Pala, in a recent New York Times Magazine, wrote about Vozrozhdenie…a remote island in the south Aral Sea (he dubbed it Anthrax Island). It was abandoned by the Soviets in 1992, and it is now owned by Kazakhstan…for many years, the Soviet Union used this island as a testing site for their biological weapons program. There were 8 to 10 warehouses, a housing complex that accommodated as many as 15,000 people in its salad days, and a 3 story lab…the “hot spot’ where most of the pathogens were stored.

Mr. Pala interviewed Gennadi Lypushkin, physician, microbiologist, and former Red Army colonel who supervised the installation on Vozrozhdenie. He had a lot to say…especially about the teams of scavengers who have removed about 200 tons of stuff from this hell-on-earth (“they are risking their lives and the lives of thousands of others every day”). Apparently the Soviet army buried large store of germs before they abandoned the island (and their bio-weapon testing program)…stuff like anthrax,
botulinum, antibiotic-resistant plague…and smallpox. A team of Kazakh and U.S. scientists torched the buildings on Anthrax Island…but according to Mr. Pala’s piece, a whole host of test tubes, petri dishes and other lab glassware survived the heat…not to mention what was underground.

Dr. Lepyoshkin made another salient point about bio-weapons in this interview…to have an ‘effect’ on one square kilometer…and here ‘effect’ means killing ½ of the population…it costs $2000 with conventional weapons, $800 with nuclear weapons, $600 with chemical weapons, and one dollar with a bio-weapon.” One dollar…the good Dr. Death also said that he had ‘no qualms’ about his work…that, like nukes, nobody…nobody…would be crazy enough to use biological weapons. Of course, he added, that was before lunatics started crashing airplanes into buildings…terrorism changed everything.

You bet…Pandora’s box is already open…the genie is out of the bottle…and it is way too late to lock the barn door because the mare split a long time ago. There are many people in the world…drunk with rage…desperate…left out…who may or may not have access to germs…we already know that there is plenty of this stuff out there…it is cheap and can be assembled in the back of a truck…what do we do if postal workers or TV journalists or politicians start dropping out with anthrax, botulinum or smallpox?? Do I get smallpox.vaccine for my kids if push comes to shove? What if they are the 1 or 2 per million to buy it? How do we as residents of a sedate nondescript midwestern city behave???

Do the Iraqis have biologicals?? Israeli intelligence (according to a recent Washington Post article) says they do, and they are stashing them plus chemical weapons in Syria. Do we reduce Baghdad to a smoking ash pit?? China, Russia, Iran and North Korea have them…probably Egypt, Libya, Sudan and Israel have bio-weapons programs up and running…should we put them on our hit list as well?? Should we, as the old Randy Newman song suggests, “..drop the big one, to see what happens”??

Sparks fly up…a phrase from the book of Job and a mantra for the late Ken Kesey and his band of pranksters…but it is hard to make sparks when you never know who will show up at half-time at the super bowl with a nasal spray…or who will put a small vial on the BART tracks in San Francisco. This is a conundrum for right-thinking people…do we continue to ignore it as we certainly have done in the past or do we outfit ourselves with hazmat suits and gas masks like some of our kin in the 1950s who built nuclear fallout shelters?? As I edit this, I notice that there are way too many question marks…does that tell you anything? At this point, I am operating somewhere between a controlled state of raging paranoia and making whoopee…during the iciest days of the cold war…we were comforted by the civility of the superpowers…nobody was going to push the nuclear button because everybody knew that it meant mutual destruction…everybody dies...and nobody wanted that. Now…you throw a suicidal maniac factor into the equation…well, I am not so comforted as I was in days gone by. Will it be, as T. S. Eliot suggests…”not with a bang but a whimper…”

Sparks fly up.